Subject: [AUDITORY] Why is it that joint speech-enhancement with ASR is not a popular research topic? From: Samer Hijazi <hijazi@xxxxxxxx> Date: Sun, 24 Jun 2018 12:22:58 -0700 List-Archive:<http://lists.mcgill.ca/scripts/wa.exe?LIST=AUDITORY>--00000000000036f36a056f68321b Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="00000000000036f366056f683219" --00000000000036f366056f683219 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8" It is easy to see that ASR would benefit from speech enhancement, and speech enhancement would benefit from ASR. But there is very limited research and publications in this direction vs the 100's of publications on stand alone ASR, why is that? --00000000000036f366056f683219 Content-Type: text/html; charset="UTF-8" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable <div dir=3D"ltr"> <div class=3D"gmail-post-author" style=3D"background-image:initial;backgrou= nd-position:initial;background-size:initial;background-repeat:initial;backg= round-origin:initial;background-clip:initial;text-decoration-style:initial;= text-decoration-color:initial;box-sizing:border-box;margin:0px 0px 24px;pad= ding:0px 128px 0px 0px;border:0px;font-variant-numeric:inherit;font-variant= -east-asian:inherit;font-stretch:inherit;line-height:inherit;vertical-align= :baseline;outline:0px;clear:both">It is easy to see that ASR would benefit = from speech enhancement, and speech<span>=C2=A0</span>enhancement would ben= efit from ASR. But there is very limited research and publications in this = direction vs the 100's of publications on stand alone ASR, why is that?= <br></div><br class=3D"gmail-Apple-interchange-newline"> </div> --00000000000036f366056f683219-- --00000000000036f36a056f68321b Content-Type: image/jpeg; name="image003.jpg" Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="image003.jpg" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-ID: <164333e6d196917eb1> X-Attachment-Id: 164333e6d196917eb1 /9j/4AAQSkZJRgABAQEAYABgAAD/2wBDAAoHBwgHBgoICAgLCgoLDhgQDg0NDh0VFhEYIx8lJCIf IiEmKzcvJik0KSEiMEExNDk7Pj4+JS5ESUM8SDc9Pjv/2wBDAQoLCw4NDhwQEBw7KCIoOzs7Ozs7 Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozs7Ozv/wAARCAB1AacDASIA AhEBAxEB/8QAHwAAAQUBAQEBAQEAAAAAAAAAAAECAwQFBgcICQoL/8QAtRAAAgEDAwIEAwUFBAQA AAF9AQIDAAQRBRIhMUEGE1FhByJxFDKBkaEII0KxwRVS0fAkM2JyggkKFhcYGRolJicoKSo0NTY3 ODk6Q0RFRkdISUpTVFVWV1hZWmNkZWZnaGlqc3R1dnd4eXqDhIWGh4iJipKTlJWWl5iZmqKjpKWm p6ipqrKztLW2t7i5usLDxMXGx8jJytLT1NXW19jZ2uHi4+Tl5ufo6erx8vP09fb3+Pn6/8QAHwEA AwEBAQEBAQEBAQAAAAAAAAECAwQFBgcICQoL/8QAtREAAgECBAQDBAcFBAQAAQJ3AAECAxEEBSEx BhJBUQdhcRMiMoEIFEKRobHBCSMzUvAVYnLRChYkNOEl8RcYGRomJygpKjU2Nzg5OkNERUZHSElK U1RVVldYWVpjZGVmZ2hpanN0dXZ3eHl6goOEhYaHiImKkpOUlZaXmJmaoqOkpaanqKmqsrO0tba3 uLm6wsPExcbHyMnK0tPU1dbX2Nna4uPk5ebn6Onq8vP09fb3+Pn6/9oADAMBAAIRAxEAPwD2aiii gAooooAKKKTpQAtQ3F3b2ozcTxxA9NzYzWZrOpeTbZS4aBM/O6JlivfHp9a5WTxGsZY6Xpplcnme Y7mb3yT/AFqJSsVGNzsX16zX7gnlHqkLY/Wq7+KrGM/PFcr9Y/8A69cg1/rl4czXkEAP8IyxH5YH 60+Oznk/1mrAn/r2B/m1Z+0ZfIjrofFWjzHb9rEZ9JFK1qxTRzoHikWRD0ZTkVwn9gSXGAuo2p55 8yzPT8HFXF8M3lk3n6RfGNx/CCQD9R0qlUE4HZUVzen+JpYpvsetQ/Z5+iyAfK/+H8q6JHEiBlzg jPIxWiaZDVh1FFFMQUUUUAFFFFABRRRQAUUUUAFFFFABRRRQAUUUUAFFFFABRRRQAUUUUAFFFFAB RRRQAUUUUAFFFFABRRRQAUUUUAFFFFABRRRQAUUUUAFFc/P4hmMzCCNPLBwC2ST70Lrt2f4IvyP+ NZ+0iX7OR0FFYY1q5P8ADH+R/wAakXVrg/wx/kaPaxH7ORsVWupBgqThF5b39qprqU5IG1OfaotR mO4Qg89W+pqoyUtiZRcdzA8TyTXCJsbagYCsHJHA4rr7yw+1WLQjAdsFSegIqlF4Xtwv765ldv8A YAUf1rOo1cuCdjndzetPSZl71uT+Fl2k2t0yt2WUZB/EVg3MM1ncm3uozFJjI5yGHqD3FZ3RdmaF tespHzVu2GpsMZauQVyprTs5unNAJnY3NpaazamOdQWxw3cVm6de3OjXQ02+YvF0hlPp6U6wuSuO at6rapqNieB5icqapSsS4mwrBlDA5Bpa5fQtUugZbWT5wnzKzduxFa/9oS/3V/KtPaRRCg2aNFZv 9oTf3U/Kk/tGb+6n5Ue1iP2cjTorNF/OxwEU/QGkOoXC9UUfUGj2kQ9mzTorL/tKf+6n5Un9pz/3 U/I0vaxD2cjVorJ/tOf+6n5Gk/tS4/up+Rp+1iHs5GvRWP8A2rcf3Y/yNJ/a1x/dj/I0vaxD2cjZ orF/te4/ux/kaP7Yuf7sf5H/ABo9rEPZyNqisT+2bn+7H+R/xpP7Zuf7sf5H/Gj2sQ9nI3KKwv7a uv7sf5H/ABpP7buv7sX5H/Gj2sQ9nI3qK5867df3IvyP+NIdeu/7kX5H/Gj2sQ9nI6Giud/t+7/u Rfkf8aT/AISC8/uRfkf8aPaxD2cjo6K5v/hIbz+5F+R/xpP+EivP7kX5H/Gn7WIezkdLRXMnxFef 3If++T/jSHxJe/3If++T/jR7SIezkdPRXLHxLff884f++T/jTT4nvv8AnnD/AN8n/Gj2kQ9nI6ui uTPii+/55wf98n/GmnxVf/8APOD/AL5P+NHtIi5GddRXHnxZqA/5Zwf98n/Gm/8ACW6jnAig/wC+ T/jR7SIezkdlRXHHxVqn/PK2/I/41G3i/U0ODFb5/wB0/wCNJVoPZjdOSO1oriP+Ey1L/nlb/wDf J/xpP+Ez1L/nlb/98n/Gq50LkZ3FFYGgeJDqsrW1xGsc4G5Sh4Yd/wAa36pNMlqwUUUUxHDrUyVC lTJXEdZMlTLUSVKtIaLEGPOjB7tTZTvvpGboCabESLqPPQMMUS8Tzf7xq6dS0JPsZzjeUV3Jgc80 6oYidvt2qWs4y5lc1as7C1Q1vTF1TTniUDz4xvhb0b0+h6VfoziqJPOreXzYgTwe4PatCyfDYqtf wC11++twMKX8xB7MM/1NPt22yitCDpbRsYrWhl+XHrWJaN8orSR8CpGUGb7HrSsOElO1vx/+vitY 1h6wN2D3rWtZ7Z4/9H82ROOWJwDjkZ9KajcXNYlNFO3DGNoH0pmck+xqWi0ydCRbsY878/Njrikc sbbMuc7vkz196ZFu3/KxX1Iqwx3Y3HOPWqWqJejKVIalnTB3DoaoJeb9Sls/Lx5cYfdnrntispNR eppGLkm10LNNpTSGmIQ0hpaaaBiGkNLSGgBppDSmmmgBDTTTjTTQAhppp1MNACUhpTSUANNNNONN NMQ00004000CGGmmp4IGuZhGvGep9BUv2GOQMILpJZACQgXrVpMTkkUDTDTmNMJos7XJ5435RrUs QBJbuKaaarbWz+dZzTcWkaRdnqT1FOoKbu4pxmT1P5VBNJvPHQVy0qcudGkpKxGaaavQaZLPAsxl iiVj8vmNjNPGjSMdq3VuxPQB+tehys53NB4em8jXrRuzPsP4jFej15XEzW12jkFWikBI9CDXqYIY BhyCMitKZnMWiiitDM4haniUuwVRkk4FQLWlpoXLkcygfKDXGld2OpuyuTMlrb7Y3Uu4HJBp8bWb MF8thnuTVEli5L/eJ5zUi0+byDl8yaaExybc4IOVNIys45IHrgdasyfNaI0nD/w+9QColBaruOLv r2FAwABTqSigY6ikozTA47xGoTxSjd5IF/mRVQZWXGOhq54n/wCRmtf+uC/+hNVSXi4b/eq0Zs3L STCj5TV1ZuPut+VZtq/yCrYk4pDIb+TcvRvyrT0og6bDgAcHP1zWTdNla1NFG7TVJPAdv50WuCdm Xf8AIpAMe/qacx9KbSfZFLuxVYqwI7VN5qf3qr0lJOwNXHzSbzgdBWRD/wAjJdf9e6fzrTrLh/5G S6/690/nWNXVx9f0ZvR2n6fqjasVV7xFZQwOeCPapzAg1GJlUGKXJAxx05FQ6f8A8fsf4/yqxYuJ HaFj80chdP611Rs0jlldMpC3eaeRUwApOSTgAZps1tJDsJKsr/dZTkGrlsVKXkfl+YxbOzONwzUM 0rfZ44/sphj8wEEk9fxpcqtcfM7kBtJftQtsrv8Arx0zSRWcs/meXtPlnBycVomKQ635mxtmM7sc dKrQ5FrqHY//AK6OVXFzOxXWykd3UPHsj+9IW+UfjUdxbSWxXfgqwyrKcg1aiUy6PJHGNzrJllHX FJdjy9LtopBiTJbB6gc0cqsPmdynC8ccoaWPzFH8OcVei+z6hbzg2yQtEu5WT/PtVGCCS5lEUYyT 19h61oXME1vbG0tYJGDcyy4+97CiN7eQStfzMemmnU01mWxKQ0tIaAGmmscCnGmmmIjD7jjGKQ07 aB0pApZgq9TTdr6Ex5kveLFjIu6SBjt85dofuDTrexltphPMypHECxKtkn2ppsk7u1VrmDySMElT 3NWnYTV3oQzv5szybQu45wO1QmpDUbGlzO1hezjzcww0w080xqRbGGprK1N5dLEOF6sfQVCafb3D 2tws0fVT09R6U0J3toSaldC6uMRjEMQ2Rj29aqozRurodrKcg+laN7YNO63VlG0kUw3YUfdPcVXj 0u9kkVDbugY4LMOBVNO5CasT6ii3VumoRDAk+WUejV3ekzfaNJtJe7RLn645rgtRnQbLK3/1MHGf 7zdzXX+EpvN0KNe8Tsn65/rWkX7xLXum1RRRWhmcSlTwyNG6uvUVAtSrXEdZpukFwRKJljLDkH1p 0dvCrAtcKwHb1rODqvJIA96ifUreLjJY+wqr36E2t1NSabzpM/wjgCmisdta5+SHj1Y0o1mT/nmn 60rNjukbIpayV1oY+aLn2NQvr0hXdFEmD0Oc0crHzI3KK5j+1ry4lCG4MQ7lRjFXbW4RL7Mmo3k7 uoVIxtEQHdjxnNNRu7CczI8SHd4qhX+7Cn8zVWY/6Q3+9UmrMJfFjlSSFRBz9M/1qFzmZv8Aeqti Walu2FFWQ9UoT8oqYNSGhZmyK19F/wCQcP8Aro1Ykh4rb0bjTl93b+dJ7Aty9SUUlQWFJS0lACVR it5V1u4uSuInhVVbPUir1JUuKlbyLjNxvbroAZlOVYqfUGkDsrblYhvUHmim1RIodlbcGIb1B5ok lklOZHZz7nNNpKBDzcTYC+c+F6Dd0pm9wGAdsN97nr9aSmmi7CwqSPE26N2Q+oOKa7tIxZ2LMe5O aDTaBipI8R3RuyH1U4pxu7n/AJ+Jf++jUZpKd2KyGmmmnGmmkAlIadTTTAQ0w080w0CGmnQOqSjd 0PGfSmGmmmgNE1VvJFEWzqW6e1QGeUf8tGqJ2ZzliSfU1VybEMp4x61AasOMjFQlPeuecJN3R005 xSsxM5FNanGmGtzne400hpTTTTAfHczwrtjmdFznCtin/brs/wDLzL/30agoFO7JshRXXeCJswXc BP3XVwPqMf0rka6DwbNs1eSI/wDLWI/mCP8A69OL94J/CdvRRRXQc5xAOKie7xKIl+9jJ9hUuM1n 3ME0FyLqJDIMYZB1x7Vxo62WSS/3jmq9zaCcowdkeMkqR7+tT2l3aXPyiQK/dG4I/CtOPTmlGUw3 0NUQYSQTKPnKOe2Bijy58/6tMfU/41vNpUg/hqJ7Jl/hpiMSWGR12rhPccmo4bc28QjjGFH/AOs1 tfZJG6IT+FRzW5hXdIVQe5FAWM0qSpyNpI6irGlW7FN0j7mPpwBVWS6jdjHbnzX/ANn7o+prS05P IjUO2T3pMcTBm+bxJdHrtfH5ACmry5PvTI5RLqN5NnOZHP6mnxdqEDL0RwKlDVXQ8U/dQA92roNK GNMh9wT+prmXeupsl8uygTuIx/KlLYcSxVS5dvM28gD9as5pjxrJjcOlKLs9QqRco2RDbO2SvUdf pVimpGsYIXvTqUndhCLjGzEqVIke0lk53xkd+1RVYscNK8LcCVCKcd7FPa4s9oqQQsmd7EB+e5FK baNprmKNCxRRtye9WIpFmuZ1YgBHDj8OKqQOXS8cnlkz+tW0iE2QTQSwld6/e6EHOaWS0niQuycD rgglfrVgMqW9izfdV2J/On3JaP7Qy2oCyDmXfwR60uVD5mUjbTCHziuExnJPWg2c4i8zZxjdjIzj 1xUl0f3Np3Aj6fjVydyJ2uIrUSKyf63zMDGKFFBzMyFVpHCIpZmOAB3p89tLAN0gXGccMDg0tqZF uYzCAZAeAT1qzdRRrCJ5Lf7PL5gym7O8dzipSuim7MqmyuBH5hj4A3EZG4D1xURicQibHyFtoOe9 a20rqj3jYNvszvzwRjpVRIXuNLRIV3MsxJGegxVOJKkV/sNwZXhEeZEXcVBHSo7i1mtgplUAN0II I/StWU/6dekEc23BB9hVJmVdNsy3QSsSPbNDikJSbHWmnSb2a4iGzymbBbkccHHWs5EaRlRRlmIA Hqa3PIkOqT3OAYXiO18jB47Vj2f/AB92/wD10X+dDVhp3JG0u9H/ACx74IDDI9z6CoLi1mt5VjkT 5nAK7Tnd9K0ZD/yF+epH/oVNMkcVxpUkhARYxk+lNxQrsoXFhc28fmSIAoODhgdp9DjpTU027mhE qRZVgSo3AMwHcDqa0b4yQQXirYCNJj80vm5Dc8ECpmfebO6tbEXBSIASCXaEI6gijlVxczsZK6az 6V9tDDdvI2lgBtA5P19qhj027mhWZEUK33dzhS30B61cZHudCl8qPcy3bSOq87Rjr9KmtIXvILaG +sVe3VPkuVkx5a+9OyHdnPnk4AyTwAK04NHkitr2S8hX5LcsnzglG7ZAPFVbOSKDVYHZsxJMPmPp nrWq1ncQzazcSpiOaFzG+4fPk5GPwpRQNmLbaXeXkXmQxgqTtUs4XcfQZ61Db6fdXUkkcceDF/rC 5ChPqT0regKz6TpzQaf9tktiQQspUxNnOSB6+tVoJ76a61EppsdzFM4E9uHBwR6EdfrT5UK7KFrZ GK9lgurQ3DCFnCxyjA44bIPSoLTSry9hEsKLsLbVZ3Cbj6DPWtuG1tbPWpY7YeWGsXZ4i27ymI5X NQacLe70S2S48qWS2mJii+0CIgHk7s9efSnYLmb/AGLqH2g24gDTKhcorgkAHHY9fao7vTbuwWN7 iMKsmQpVgwyOo471sWzXJ1vVZLyMQTtaSEqDwOBjB78d6oy4/wCEVsx/08vx+FKyBNmZWl4em8jX rRv7z7D+IIrNqSCUwXMUw6xurfkam9mU9j1OikBBAI5BorqOY4pakABFRqMHBqVa4TrIJ7C3uP8A WRKx9SKr/wBlmL/j3ubiH/dkOP1rSAzTtlO4WMvyNSX7upzn/eAP9KRodSPXUHP/AAAVreXR5VPm CxiPa3h+9fz/AIED+QqrJp6Z3Sb5T6yMW/nXSGAHtUbWat2p8wrHOGbyBhVwB7VE2rshznGK6CXS 0ftVC48PLIpxVJoVmc7YSDZIe7E/zq/HwBUTeG7+2kLW7gqT91hUq6frHTy4h780CJg2KDKB3pg0 bVJPvTqg/wBlami8NsSDPNJJ7E8UaBZiWq/a5wq/cB+Zu2K6dJwenFZ9vYLAoVBgCrccRFSyki2r Zp+ajRcVJUFEVzIY4+OrcA+lUd7D+I/nWhIgkQqe9Vvsbd3FYVIyb0OinKKWpPFJ5kYboe9OoACg AcAdKK2Wxg99BKSlpKYCUhpaSgBKT27UUlACGg/nRSUAIaTNKaQ0CGmkpTSGgQhppp1NNMBpphp5 phoAYT+Q6UwnGRk4NPNMamAwk+uM0w9COx7U80w0xDGqNieOTxT2qNqAGkkdCR9DTM4OQcH2pxph oQCGr0epwm0itrzT4rpYM+WxdkIB5wcdRVA02qEyzfXsuoXbXEoVSQFCr0UDoBUApopwoBBSHkEU tJUjPTdKm+0aVay9d0S5+uOaKoeE5TLoMSn/AJZsyfrn+tFdS1RzPRlqbRbSaVpfnQsckKeM00aF aj+KX/vof4UUUuSPYfNLuL/YtsP4pPzH+FO/se2/vSfmP8KKKXJHsHPLuH9kW/8Aek/MUv8AZNv/ AHpPzooo5I9g55dw/sm3/vSfnR/ZNv8A3n/MUUUckewc8u4f2Tb/AN5/zFH9k2/95/zooo5I9g55 dw/si39X/MUn9kW3q/5iiijkj2Dnl3D+yLb1f8xR/Y9t6v8AnRRT5I9g55dw/se29X/MUv8AZFsO 7/nRRS5I9g55dxf7Kt/7z/nR/Zdv/ef86KKOSPYOeXcP7Kt/7z/nSf2Vb/3pPzooo5I9g55dw/sm 3/vSfnR/ZNv/AHpPzooo5I9g55dw/si3/vSfnSf2Rb/3pPzFFFHJHsHPLuH9j2/96T8xSf2Pbf3p PzH+FFFHJHsHPLuH9jW396T8x/hR/Ytt/ek/Mf4UUUckewc8u4n9i2396T/vof4Uf2Ja/wB6T/vo f4UUUckewc8u4f2Ja/3pf++h/hSf2Ha/3pf++h/hRRT5I9g55dw/sK1/vS/99D/Ck/sG0/vy/wDf Q/wooo5I9g55dw/sC0/vy/8AfQ/wpP8AhH7T+/L/AN9D/Ciijkj2Dml3E/4R6z/vzf8AfQ/wpP8A hHLM/wAc3/fQ/wAKKKOSPYOaXcT/AIRqy/vzf99D/CkPhmxP8c3/AH0P8KKKOSPYOaXcafC9if8A lpP/AN9D/Ck/4RWwP/LSf/vof4UUUcsewc0hD4T08/8ALSf/AL6H+FJ/wiGnH/lpcf8AfY/wooo5 Y9g5mN/4Q7Tj/wAtLj/vsf4Un/CG6b/z0uP++x/hRRRyxDmYf8IZpv8Az1uf++x/hSf8IXpn/PW5 /wC+x/hRRRyoOZh/whemf89bn/vsf4Uv/CGab/z1uf8Avsf4UUUcqDmYf8IZpv8Az1uf++x/hR/w hmmf89Ln/vsf4UUUcsQ5mbNnZwWFslvbpsjToOufc0UUVRJ//9k= --00000000000036f36a056f68321b--