Subject: Musical vs everyday listening From: Brian Gygi <bgygi@xxxxxxxx> Date: Tue, 9 Jan 2007 16:15:58 -0800 List-Archive:<http://lists.mcgill.ca/scripts/wa.exe?LIST=AUDITORY>Peter - On the record, I generally try to stay away from hypotheses about mechanisms and try to stick to functional descriptions (off the record is a different story). In any case, this distinction between "musical" and "everyday" listening was first formally proposed, as far as I know, by Bill Gaver in What Do We Hear in the World (1993). His argument was based almost wholly on intuition. Since then, various researchers (such as myself) has been trying to provide empirical evidence for this. If you are at the spring ASA in Utah (plug time) Valeriy Shafiro and I are co-chairing a special session on topics in environmental sound research and that is one of the issues we hope to tackle. Best Brian Peter Lennox wrote: > what you and Brian are implying here is that 'musical listening' is > substantively different from the kind of listening that has evolved in > the face of normal environmental conditions where survival issues > naturally take precedence. This places musical listening in a context of > "exaptation" > where 'normal' mechanisms have been 'hijacked' for some other use, > outside of the usual evolutionery pressures - this is Stephen Pinker's > position, i think. However, I feel it can't be so black-and-white - > environments aren't always so urgent (and in any case, being a stranger > in morocco should awaken one's survival instincts sufficiently to > suppress any luxurious non-survival-oriented perceptual styles. I would > accept that musical listening might be somewhat analogous to using > vision to appreciate a 'nice view' where imme3diate threat is clearly > absent - but the analogy can't be pushed too far; our recreational use > of vision seems somehow less abstract - it's more usually of 'things' > (even if colour is exaggerated) whereas music is the 'thing' in itself - > with exceptions in both cases, of course. > regards > ppl > Dr. Peter Lennox > S.P.A.R.G. > Signal Processing Applications Research Group > University of Derby > http://sparg.derby.ac.uk > Int. tel: 1775 >