[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Auditory perceptual blocks, and criterion shifts

Thank you Richard
Exactly the kind of study I am interested in viewing.

On 2012-11-26, at 4:09 PM, Richard M. Warren wrote:

The comments described by Eldad Tsabary today may be an example of a general perceptual effect described in the article ["Criterion Shift Rule and Perceptual Homeostasis," Warren, 1995, Psychological Review, 92, 574-584.].  This article considers that "...the bases employed for evaluative judgments are displaced in the direction of a preceding or simultaneously encountered value.  Consequences of this displacement have been discovered and re-discovered numerous times, and appear in the literature in many guises."  As discussed in some detail, these include what have been called adaptation with negative after-effectsattunementdiabatic effect, persistence effect, and the Law of Contrast.  In vision, it has been observed with both static and dynamic displays, in hearing with lateralization shifts and in the many studies involving phonetic boundary effects in psycholinguistics.



Richard M. Warren
Research Professor 
  and Distinguished Professor Emeritus
Department of Psychology
University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
PO Box 413
Milwaukee, WI  53201
(414) 229-5328

On Nov 25, 2012, at 12:24 PM, eldad tsabary wrote:

Hi all,
I am looking for some ideas and literature on two concepts relevant to ear training.

1. perceptual blocks - the case where a lack of perceptual flexibility, inability to change attentional focus, or hear at a different structural level, or any other aspect of perception, prevents ear training students from discriminating, segregating, or identifying sonic or musical parameters despite regular practice. I have used the term "perceptual block" to describe such instances, though in the literature, this term is usually associated with theories of creativity (and while I find some parallels , these concepts are quite different).

One of many such blocks, for example, could be (in the tonal domain) a perceptual habit that could be described, perhaps, as "tonal interference." In such cases, the students seem to listen to a certain interval in the context of previous tonal stimuli and may get thrown off by that contextual modality. A simple example of that is in listening to a minor third E-G right after hearing the major third C-E. In my experience, students often hear the minor third in the context of a C major triad and therefore hear it as having a major modality (or "feel"). 

This is only one type of example. I am looking for any literature that deal (more widely or more specifically) with the concept of auditory organization being stuck on a certain interpretation, inhibiting skill acquisition.

2. perceptual guides or anchors - the case where ear training students find a relatively reliable perceptual reference point that allows them to identify a certain sonic or musical parameter by comparison. An example from the tonal domain, again, may be the technique of learning how scale degrees sound by comparing them in the mind's ear to the tonic as a steady anchor. In another example, students practicing microtonal discrimination (down to about 5 cents differences) discovered that the acoustics of the room had an effect on the spatial perception of microtonal variation in pure tones. They used their spatial perception as an anchoring mechanism to recognizing microtonal differences. 

The second example is of course very different from the first, but I am interested in both and more. I am looking for any literature that deals with perceptual organization strategies (in attentive processing) that can be used to acquire aural skills by providing a reliable reference point.

I would also love some ideas about these concepts.

Many thanks